Asset Protection for Melbourne Professionals: A Guide for Doctors, Accountants, and Architects

Melbourne’s professional landscape is a dynamic and demanding environment. As a doctor, accountant, or architect, you’ve dedicated years to honing your expertise and building a successful practice. However, with success comes significant responsibility and, unfortunately, exposure to a unique set of financial and legal risks. In a litigious society, safeguarding your hard-earned assets is not just a matter of financial prudence; it’s a critical component of a sustainable and prosperous career.

This article provides a comprehensive overview of asset protection strategies tailored for Melbourne’s professionals. We will explore the specific risks you face, the foundational role of insurance, and the sophisticated structuring techniques that can create a robust shield for your personal and business assets.

Understanding Your Risk Profile: More Than Just a Job

Professionals in fields like medicine, accounting, and architecture are held to an exceptionally high standard of care. This exposes you to risks that extend far beyond the typical business challenges of market fluctuations and overheads.

Professional Negligence Claims: This is the most significant and apparent risk. A dissatisfied client, a patient with an adverse outcome, or a construction project that encounters unforeseen issues can lead to a lawsuit.

Personal Liability: For professionals operating as sole traders or in partnerships, there is no legal distinction between personal and business assets. This means your family home, investment properties, and personal savings could be at risk to satisfy a business-related debt or judgment.

Business and Investment Risks: Beyond professional liability, your assets are also exposed to a range of other risks, including:

• Employee Disputes: Claims of unfair dismissal or harassment can be costly and time-consuming.
• Contractual Disputes: Disagreements with suppliers, landlords, or clients can escalate to legal action.
• Investment Losses: The performance of your investment portfolio can impact your overall wealth.
• Personal and Family Law Matters: A relationship breakdown can have significant financial consequences.

The Foundation of Asset Protection: Insurance

Before delving into complex legal structures, it’s crucial to have the right insurance policies in place. Insurance acts as your first line of defence, absorbing the initial impact of a claim.

Professional Indemnity Insurance: This is non-negotiable for any practising professional. It covers you for claims of negligence, errors, or omissions in the provision of your professional services. Ensure your policy limit is adequate for the scale and nature of your work.

Public Liability Insurance: This covers you for claims of personal injury or property damage to third parties that occur in the course of your business activities.

Life, TPD, and Income Protection Insurance: These policies are essential for protecting you and your family from the financial consequences of illness, injury, or death.

While insurance is fundamental, it is not a complete solution. Policies have limits and exclusions, and a significant claim could exceed your coverage. This is where strategic asset structuring becomes paramount.

The Structure Stack: Layering Your Defences

A ‘structure stack’ is a multi-layered approach to asset ownership that segregates your personal assets from your business risks. By holding assets in different legal entities, you can create a series of firewalls that make it difficult for a creditor to access your entire wealth.

Here’s a look at the most common entities used in a structure stack:

1. The Family Trust (Discretionary Trust):

The family trust is the cornerstone of many asset protection strategies in Australia. A trust is a legal relationship where a trustee (often a corporate trustee for added protection) holds assets for the benefit of beneficiaries.

• Asset Protection: Assets held in a discretionary trust are generally not considered the property of any individual beneficiary. This means that if a beneficiary is sued, the assets in the trust are typically protected.
• Tax Flexibility: A discretionary trust allows the trustee to distribute income to beneficiaries in a tax-effective manner. For example, income can be distributed to family members on lower tax brackets.
• Succession Planning: A trust can provide a clear framework for the transfer of wealth to the next generation.

2. The Corporate Trustee:

Using a company as the trustee of your family trust adds another layer of protection. If the trust is sued, the liability of the corporate trustee is limited to the assets of the trust itself. This prevents the personal assets of the directors of the trustee company from being exposed.

3. The ‘At-Risk’ Entity: Your Trading Entity

This is the entity through which you conduct your professional practice. It is the entity that is most exposed to risk. The goal is to ensure that this entity holds minimal assets. This could be a company (Pty Ltd) or a partnership of trusts.

4. The ‘Safe’ Entity: Your Asset-Holding Entity

This is the entity that holds your valuable assets, such as your family home, investment properties, and share portfolio. This entity should have no exposure to the risks of your professional practice. A common approach is to have a family trust as the asset-holding entity.

The Service Trust Model: A Sophisticated Strategy

The service trust model is a powerful strategy for professionals, particularly those operating in a partnership or group practice. It involves establishing a separate entity (the service trust) to provide administrative and other services to the professional practice.

How it Works:

1. The Professional Practice: This is the entity that generates the professional income (e.g., a partnership of doctors).
2. The Service Trust: This is a separate entity (often a trust with a corporate trustee) that is controlled by the professionals or their families. The service trust employs the administrative staff, owns the office equipment, and leases the premises to the professional practice.
3. The Service Agreement: A formal service agreement is put in place between the professional practice and the service trust. The practice pays a fee to the service trust for the services it provides.

Benefits of a Service Trust:

• Asset Protection: The service trust quarantines valuable assets (such as the business premises and equipment) from the risks of the professional practice.
• Income Splitting: The profits generated by the service trust can be distributed to the beneficiaries of the trust (e.g., the professionals’ spouses or family members) in a tax-effective manner.
• Superannuation Contributions: The service trust can make superannuation contributions for its employees (the administrative staff), which can be a tax-effective way to build retirement savings.

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) scrutinises service trust arrangements, so it is essential that they are set up and operated correctly. The fees charged by the service trust must be commercially justifiable and reflect the market value of the services provided.

A Practical Example: Dr. Smith of Toorak

Dr. Smith is a successful surgeon in Melbourne. She owns her own home in Toorak, an investment property in South Yarra, and a significant share portfolio. She is a director of her incorporated medical practice, “Melbourne Surgical Excellence Pty Ltd.”

Initial Structure (High Risk):

• Dr. Smith owns her home and investment property in her own name.
• Her medical practice owns the expensive surgical equipment.
• Dr. Smith is the sole shareholder of the practice.

In this scenario, a successful negligence claim against Dr. Smith or her practice could expose all her assets, including her family home.

Improved Structure (Lower Risk):

• The Smith Family Trust: A discretionary trust is established with a corporate trustee, “Smith Holdings Pty Ltd.” Dr. Smith and her husband are the directors of the corporate trustee.
• Asset Ownership: The Smith Family Trust owns the family home, the investment property, and the share portfolio.
• The Practice: “Melbourne Surgical Excellence Pty Ltd” continues to be the trading entity. It owns no significant assets.
• The Service Trust: “Melbourne Surgical Services Trust” is established. It owns the surgical equipment and employs the administrative staff. It leases the equipment and provides administrative services to the practice for a commercial fee.

In this improved structure, Dr. Smith’s personal assets are protected within the family trust. The valuable surgical equipment is housed in a separate service trust, insulated from the risks of the practice.

Conclusion: A Proactive Approach to Wealth Preservation

As a Melbourne-based professional, your financial success is the result of years of hard work and dedication. It is imperative that you take a proactive approach to protecting your assets from the unique risks you face.

While insurance is the foundation of any asset protection plan, a well-designed structure stack, potentially incorporating a service trust, can provide a formidable shield for your wealth. The strategies outlined in this article are not “set and forget” solutions. They require careful planning, expert advice, and ongoing review to ensure they remain effective as your circumstances and the legal and financial landscape evolve.

We strongly recommend that you seek advice from a legal firm with expertise in asset protection and wealth management for professionals. A tailored strategy can provide you with the peace of mind that comes from knowing your financial future is secure.

*

Disclaimer: This article provides general information and is not a substitute for professional legal advice. Your circumstances are unique, and you should consult with a lawyer to discuss your specific needs.

To discuss a tailored asset protection strategy for your circumstances, contact the specialist wealth management and legal team at our Melbourne office today.